Research in verbal behavior has allowed us to analyze development as behavior change and thus to develop teaching tactics from behavior analysis that are derived from the theory of VBD. Agreement NNX16AC86A, Is ADS down? View the academic calendar, district and school events, and community-sponsored events. After all, variety is the spice of life. This trend might be expected to continue with Participant B yielding the next highest percentage, followed by Participant C, and lastly Participant D (which follows the participants ages in years from oldest to youngest). Bruce, Catherine D., John Ross, Tara Flynn, and Rich McPherson. Here is another example (this repeats with a new problem, for example 2 + 2 = __). Kinesthetic learning, which values movement and creativity over technological skills, is most commonly used to augment traditional types of instruction the theory being that requiring students to do . FOIA Can students research the history of a scientific concept and explain how understanding of the concept changed over time as research findings provided new insights and information? Demonstration, or clearly showing (a gamut that ranges from mere pointing to more sophisticated strategies such as chemical reactions), can possibly be used in portraying ideas such as defining words. When your child is absent it is important you let us . What is a DOL? Digital Classrooms means rethinking many commonplace teaching strategies in classrooms. Exhibitions are both a learning experience and a form of performance assessment that enable students to demonstrate the achievement of expected learning competencies for a course, learning experience, subject area, or grade level, including the content-area and cross-curricular competencies required for promotion and graduation. Prior to conducting naming experience sessions, experimenters identified 2D non-contrived stimuli that participants could not respond to as a listener or a speaker. Fig.4)4) than he did for all other objectives. In a new paper, Harvard researchers show for the first time that research-based online STEM demonstrations not only can teach students more, but can be just as enjoyable. that were occasionally used for certain objectives (see Table Table2),2), and preferred stimuli (i.e., toys, edibles, etc.) AI for Educators online course:Its a four-week course, offered in the spring, in the summer, and during back-to-school time. Providing students the opportunity to demonstrate their learning progress and achievement is the cornerstone of the districts approach to proficiency-based education, promotion, and graduation. Unlike children with naming, children who lacked naming could not learn from observing the teachers instructional-demonstrations. Demonstrations of learningmay be evaluated by a teacher or group of teachers, but in some cases review teams or panels of peers, community members, and outside expertssuch as local business leaders or scientistscontribute to the evaluation process or provide students with constructive feedback. Effect of the establishment of naming on learning from teacher demonstrations by children with autism. Video by Greg Kestin. During the transition to a proficiency-based system of teaching and learning, districts and schools will need to review and possibly revise existing policies, while also creating new policies that address emerging models, practices, and learning experiences. The Glossary of Education Reform welcomes your comments and suggestions. The current crisis has suddenly and drastically changed schools and learning. Both the demonstration of naming and learning through IDLUs involve components of observing both auditory and visual stimuli in combination. See lots of examples of demonstration of learning -- and how . character (self-discipline, empathy, integrity, resilience, and courage); real-world problem-solving (filtering, analysis, and synthesis); Conduct a fluent conversation in a foreign language about a piece of writing in that language. When the summer comes around, its definitely time to relax, disconnect and recharge your batteries. B. PortfoliosAs a companion to personal learning plans and exhibitions, students at East High School are encouraged to develop a portfolio of their academic work, progress, and achievement. As such, the same procedure should be replicated with students with disabilities who have naming to test whether the same effects emerge. A study conducted by Coon and Miguel (2012) found that recent exposure to an instructional procedure may influence the efficacy of that procedure. Ademonstration of learningis typically both a learning experience in itself and a means of evaluating academic progress and achievement. 500 7th Avenue, 8th Floor How might we utilize DoL/portfolios to provide opportunities for students to explore and become who they want to be in the world? learning and memory strategies, a summary of research on undergraduate student metacognition with regard to these strategies, and a collection of classroom demonstrations that allows students to experience real-time the effectiveness of specific learning and memory strategies. In the following experiment, we tested the extent to which it is more efficient to use IDLUs than standard learn units (SLUs) when teaching children who have the naming cusp. However, for a child with naming, an instructional demonstration of the task alone would result in that child emitting the correct response that includes both the listener and speaker components without direct instruction on each component, i.e., the student would be able to both select and arrange the pictures as a listener, and tell the story that accompanies the pictures as a speaker. Furthermore, because these participants were able to respond to multiple components of the stimuli during the naming experiences, the use of IDLUs proved to be an effective teaching method. The integration of speaker and listener responses: A theory of verbal development. For example, demonstrations of learning can help teachers determine whether students have acquired skills that cannot be easily evaluated by traditional tests or papers, including the ability to apply skills and knowledge learned in one subject areasuch as English language arts, math, or historyto problems in other subject areas or domains. Objectives were individualized across participants based on their unique skill deficits. Competency-based learning is an approach to education that focuses on the student's demonstration of desired learning outcomes as central to the learning process. Child and adolescent development: A behavioral systems approach. Allow students the opportunity to keep their demonstrations of learning in a digital portfolio, where they can start to curate their learning journey and be able to see growth over time. July 26-27. Unconsequated probe trials for listener responses consisted of asking the participant to point to a target 2-D stimulus within a counterbalanced array of three stimuli (one target stimulus and two non-target stimuli, all hypothesized to be unknown). Chair is, because a chair is a thing. All sessions during Phase 2 were conducted within the participants classroom. For students who have difficulty learning from IDLUs, it is logical to argue that perhaps they do not demonstrate certain verbal developmental cusps, such as conditioned reinforcement for observing one or more of the stimuli incorporated into the presentation of the model (i.e., they may not have observing responses for the auditory components and/or the visual components of the model), which impedes their ability to learn from lecture-style lessons. Because the objectives were individualized, differences between objectives could have influenced the rates at which they were acquired. Thankfully, technology allows students to demonstrate their learning in rich and authentic ways. Teacher: Put these numbers in order (gives student 3 numbers), Teacher: Im going to show you how to put these numbers in order: First comes 1, then 2, then 3. Mr. Towne first conducted a demonstration and had students write and discuss in their groups to determine a precise definition of temperature, using academic vocabulary. Prior to beginning instruction, baseline-screening sessions were conducted for all objectives taught during the experiment. The goal: to determine where to aim in order to hit the falling monkey. 1129 20th Street NW, Suite 800 Educators may also create any number of homegrown terms for demonstrations of learningfar too many to catalog here. Some examples include, but are not limited to, projects such as: NOTE: Districts will need to modify this policy to address all relevant school-based systems that support the completion of performance-based assessments and projects. There are benefits to using demonstrations as a teaching method when teaching agriculture. For students who . Sessions come out July 15 to Aug 15. infused.link/ai-infused Register to get the ChatGPT and AI in Education Resources Slides, including: AI bias and misinformation help guide, quick start guide for teachers and students, and AI lesson upgrade ideas. Students present a purposeful body of evidence that shows effort, progress and achievement over time, including reflection on their learning journey. Thus, it is not just that the learning outcome is addressed in a particular experience, but that it is also assessed, along with the means by which the learning is assessed. Barnes-Holmes D, Barnes-Holmes Y, Cullinan V. Relational frame theory and Skinners verbal behavior: A possible synthesis. The ADS is operated by the Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory under NASA Cooperative To ensure that students have the support they need to successfully complete exhibitions that meet high academic standards, the schools educators, counselors, advisors, and community mentors will provide all necessary and appropriate guidance, scaffolding, and resources. Works of art, illustration, music, drama, dance, or performance. Construct and program a robot capable of performing a difficult physical task. Although repetition is a tried and true method for learning, performing the same academic exercises over and over again really left a great deal to be desired. To be eligible for a diploma, all students will successfully complete a culminating demonstration of learning during their junior or senior years of high school that demonstrates achievement of content-area and cross-curricular competencies.D. Materials consisted of the following: Small personal whiteboards on which participants could write their responses, dry erase markers and erasers, an easel for the teacher to write instructions, small manipulatives (i.e., blocks, counting bears, etc.) These data path trends, with one exception for Participant Cs math objectives (addressed in the discussion), signify that instruction was more efficient under the IDLU condition. Experimenters also graphed the cumulative correct responses under each condition in the exact order in which the responses occurred for each participant, and a comparison of the data path trends for each condition was made. Then students construct knowledge, keep record of the journey, and show their learning with digital products like Flipgrid, Seesaw, Adobe Spark and Book Creator, or another online learning tool. All students are expected to demonstrate achievement of the knowledge, skills . If students can learn from models, this type of instruction may be more efficient than instruction involving only direct consequences of reinforcement or error correction procedures. The mean learn units-to-criterion graph also demonstrated a lower mean number of learn units to meet objectives under the IDLU conditions. Allow students the choice to respond to the question in a way that fits their learning style. But it does give the teacher an idea of how proficient the student is and how much they've learned. Many examples have been provided within the literature demonstrating that prior to the establishment of certain cusps, children did not learn, or learned very slowly, even when best practice operant teaching procedures were used (Greer & Han, 2015; Greer, Pistoljevic, Cahill, & Du, 2011b; Pereira-Delgado, Greer, & Speckman, 2008; ). Get info, speakers, session links and more here. All online, all free. "Lesson Study and Demonstration Classrooms: Examining the Effects of Two Models of Teacher Professional Development." Donate today to join us in the fight to give every student the education they deserve. In teaching through demonstration, students are set up to potentially conceptualize class material more effectively as shown in a study which specifically focuses on chemistry demonstrations presented by teachers. Carnerero JJ, Prez-Gonzlez LA. For a mean of every two sessions run under the IDLU condition, one objective was met. Using the same participants in Phase 2, we compared rates of learning under two instructional methods using a series of repeated AB designs where conditions (IDLUs versus SLUs) were counterbalanced across dyads and replicated across participants. Naming experience sessions were used to test for the presence of naming. This is often done in plays, movies, and film. Playing occurred via incorporating 2-D stimuli into play scenarios with participants preferred toys and items (i.e., Look, percent is going in the truck or Dont let the dinosaur eat tilde!). An incorrect response consisted of the participant emitting a non-target response or not emitting a response at all. No expiration. All those words begin with the sound buh. Put more simply, demonstration means 'to clearly show'.[1]. 2023 San Francisco Unified School District, Learn about our mission, our Vision, Values, Goals, and Guardrails, and the districtwide plans supporting them, Meet the commissioners and find meeting agendas and schedules, Meet the superintendent and our leadership team, and recognize outstanding employees, Learn how budgets and the Local Control and Accountability Plan are created, Find out how to submit a records request or contact departments and schools, Learn when and how to apply for Infant, Toddler, and Prekindergarten programs, Learn when and how to apply for grades TK-13 and how our assignment system works, Get tips on how to search for schools that fit your child, Search for schools by programs, location, and grade level, Learn how our schools contribute to the community and how to find resources, See what we're teaching, how we assess student learning, and opportunities for learning outside the classroom, Learn about special education assessments, Individual Education Plans (IEPs) and more, Find out about English Learner programs, assessments and reclassification, We have language pathways for learning non-English languages and for English Learners, Learn more about student technology tools, school libraries, textbooks and classroom materials, Find out how we're redesigning learning in and out of the classroom, See how we are supporting Special Education students, English Learners, migrant students, foster youth, LGBTQ youth, and refugee and immigrant youth, Find out how to request a transcript, make up credits, request transportation, or learn about available counseling services, Find out how to get free meals and learn about health requirements for enrolling in school, Check out our family toolkit for school engagement, learn how to sign up for school and district notifications, request translation or interpretation, or report a concern, Learn about school safety and emergency preparation, Know your rights as an SFUSD family member or student and learn about SFUSD policies. Establishing naming in typically developing two-year-old children as a function of multiple exemplar speaker and listener experiences. October 22, 2018 View transcript Schools That Work Kettle Moraine High School Public, Suburban Grades 9-12 Wales, WI What makes this a SCHOOL THAT WORKS Share This Story Filed Under Assessment In most cases, exhibitions are built on a project-based, inquiry-based, or community-based methodology that engages students in a multidisciplinary project, an investigation of real-world problems, or an exploration of issues that affect their community. Outline of design and sequence of curricular objectives taught in Phase 2, - Responding with number of 3D objects (1-3, VF of 5). AnimationAvatar 5. that were used as reinforcers after each instructional session. Next, the model predicts pseudo-labels for the pseudo-inputs via zero-shot prompting. In: Wittrock MC, editor. Defining demonstration of learningis complicated by the fact that educators use many different terms when referring to the general concept, and the terms may or may not be used synonymously from place to place. For example, if Participant A did not look at the index card with a percent sign on it two times during the session while the name was being spoken, but did successfully observe all other stimuli while their names were being spoken, that session would consist of 22 exposure attempts (20 successful exposures and 2 unsuccessful exposures). This project presents an approach for teaching robots that relies on the key features and the general approach people use when teaching each other: first give a demonstration, then allow the learner to refine the acquired capabilities by practicing under the teacher's supervision, involving a small number of trials. A series of AB designs (Kennedy, 2005) repeated within and counterbalanced between participants were used to demonstrate the efficiency of IDLU instruction over SLU instruction. What Can Educators Do When Familiar With This Technique? A blueprint for better teacher evaluations. Here are dozens of opportunities including a PD bingo choice board! As a library, NLM provides access to scientific literature. Figures Figures33 and and44 display the cumulative correct responses for mathematics and reading objectives across each condition for Dyads 1 and 2 respectively. These findings, together with prior findings, suggest that the onset of naming allows children to learn faster when instructional demonstrations are incorporated into lessons. Greer RD, Speckman J. These cusps consisted of any critical behavior change that brought the organisms behavior into contact with new contingencies that have even more far-reaching consequences (e.g., learning to crawl, or first instances of speech that affect the behavior of a listener). The number of attempted exposures varied from session to session depending on how many minuses occurred before achieving the 20 successful exposures. Report an issue - Last updated: 04/14/2022 In the end, students from both groups who watched the online video scored higher on tests on the material presented, without any reported decrease in enthusiasm. This figure demonstrates the participants mean correct responding during first trials and during first session blocks compared across both SLU and IDLU conditions in phase 2. Awesome Teacher Summer: PD bingo choice board:There are lots of free PD opportunities over the summer! The 7 Conditions of Learning: Demonstration Lois Letchford This is Part II of exploring Professor Brian Cambourne's 7 Conditions of Learning. San Francisco, CA94102415-241-6000. The findings of the present study in combination with the findings of Greer and colleagues (2011) would suggest that an analysis of the learners cusps may be most helpful when determining what types of instruction will be beneficial for yielding correct responding from students. The site is secure. Use, Smithsonian Demonstration Learning is a paradigm in which an agent learns to perform a task by imitating the behavior of an expert shown in demonstrations. Dyad 1s intervention data showing learn units to mastery of mathematics and reading objectives across SLU and IDLU conditions in phase 2, Dyad 2s intervention data showing learn units to mastery of mathematics and reading objectives across SLU and IDLU conditions in phase 2, Dyad 1s cumulative records of correct responding to master mathematics and reading objectives under the SLU and IDLU conditions in phase 2, Dyad 2s cumulative records of correct responding to master mathematics and reading objectives under the SLU and IDLU conditions in phase 2. Participants can earn up to 16 hours of professional development credit. Inclusion in an NLM database does not imply endorsement of, or agreement with, This layer of mapping allows for examination on issues of alignment as well as gaps. John Stuart Mill's philosophy of scientific method. 2014 Great Schools Partnership | 482 Congress Street, Suite 500 | Portland, ME 04101 | 207.773.0505 | greatschoolspartnership.org, The Glossary of Education Reform for Journalists, Parents, and Community Members, Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License, Oral presentations, speeches, or spoken-word poems, Video documentaries, multimedia presentations, audio recordings, or podcasts, Works of art, illustration, music, drama, dance, or performance, Print or online publications, including websites or blogs, Galleries of print or digital photography, Scientific experiments, studies, and reports, Physical products such as a models, sculptures, dioramas, musical instruments, or robots, Presentations or slideshows that provide a summary of the skills and knowledge students have learned, A project, presentation, product, or portfolio that teachers use as a form of, A multifaceted assignment that serves as a culminating academic and intellectual experience for students, typically during their final year of high school or middle school, or at the end of an academic program or. Thus, it is possible that the procedures in Phase 1 may have influenced the results of the comparisons in Phase 2. A number of limitations occurred that should be taken into consideration when interpreting these findings. 10 is, Teacher holds up an index card with a word written on it and waits for the student to emit the tact for the word, Teacher chooses 4 target words. These results are consistent with research demonstrating that simple exposure is enough for children to contact name-learning opportunities if those children have the naming cusp/capability within their repertoire (Cahill & Greer, 2014; Carnerero & Prez-Gonzlez, 2014; Childers & Tomasello, 2002; Corwin & Greer, in press). But in the end, it will give students the freedom to find out how they learn best, and teachers will have the freedom to find new ways to assess students. For the purpose of this study, one naming experience session was defined as the entire block of 20 single exposures. This is his 48th column for Independent School. Examples of antecedents across select objectives for both conditions in Phase 2, *Note. "Effects of Demonstration Laboratory on Student Learning". Assess media coverage of a global event from various cultural/national perspectives. Table Table11 contains information on the 2-D stimuli used to screen each participant. Now Im going to show you a different example: First comes 5, then 6, and then 7. Portfolios are a comprehensive collection of work samples compiled to demonstrate the achievement of proficiency on content-area and cross-curricular competencies. The results of Phase 2 suggest that preschool students with naming benefit greatly from teacher-modeled instruction. Attending school every day gives your child the best opportunity and access to a wide range of learning, wellbeing and social connections. 1) Timeglider 2) Fodey.com 3) Voki 4) Bubbl.us 6) Vocaroo 7) Sharalike Tools that can help students & teachers do so are listed below. They want their academic work to be relevant, engaging, and fun. The previous article, published in 2013 by Miller and Eric Mazur, Balkanski Professor of Physics and Applied Physics, showed that students often misunderstand lecture demonstrations. Demonstrations of learningare typically designed to encourage students to think critically, solve challenging problems, and develop important skills and work habits such as written and oral communication, public speaking, research, teamwork, planning, self-sufficiency, goal setting, or technological and online literacyi.e., skills that will help better prepare them for college, modern careers, and adult life. HHS Vulnerability Disclosure, Help As I now reflect upon her and my learning experiences fondly, I had only one criticism I did the same type of work day in and day out. Teacher then says These words say and, but, if, and that. On the origins of naming and other symbolic behavior. In any case, control and intervention procedures were consistent with the method of difference that is the criterion for experimental design (Mills, 1950). CD Bruce, Aug. 2009. Demonstrations of Learning: Exhibitions, Portfolios, and Capstones. We have an incredible group of scientists who present live demos for our students, but very few schools have these dedicated resources, said co-author Logan McCarty, director of science education in the Department of Physics, who oversees Harvards Lecture Demonstration team. At schools that anchor in portfolios or other demonstrations of learning: Students are provided with time, space and support to set goals, assess learning, track progress and present their growth. If students cannot learn from observing models and following spoken instructions, this type of instruction is not effective, as some of the above studies report. Finally, Mr. Towne asks each student to write the definition of temperature independently in their own words. Simply choosing from four provided answers tells us little about their learning journey. If participants responded with 20% accuracy or below (i.e., 1/5 correct or less), the objective was considered novel. Large language models (LMs) have exhibited superior in-context learning (ICL) ability to adopt to target tasks by prompting with a few input-output demonstrations. Fig.22 and Fig. Created by the Great Schools Partnership, the GLOSSARY OF EDUCATION REFORM is a comprehensive online resource that describes widely used school-improvement terms, concepts, and strategies for journalists, parents, and community members. Watch Video: Ms. Hurley, 2nd Grade English Language Arts, Watch Video: Mr. Paulsen, 10th Grade Geometry, Watch Video: Mr. Towne, 10th-12th AP Physics. For example, both exhibitions and portfolios often require appropriate scaffolding and support throughout the grades to prepare students to successfully complete in-depth culminating presentations at the end of high school. Another limitation to note is the potential for carry-over effects between Phase 1 and Phase 2. In Phase 2, Participants were divided into dyads. Our research suggests that when live demos are unavailable, videos can provide students with an equally effective or possibly even more effective learning experience, said co-author Louis Deslauriers, director of science teaching and learning in the Faculty of Arts and Sciences. Rosales-Ruiz J, Baer DM. The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest. Declaim with passion and from memory a passage that is meaningful of ones own or from the cultures literature or history. These data demonstrate that when the IDLUs were used with students with the naming capability, objectives were met more than twice as fast, with a ratio of 1:2.3 objectives being met per session block under the SLU condition (1 objective) as compared to the IDLU condition (2.3 objectives). The "essential demonstrations" that follow could be gathered in a student's electronic portfolio that follows him or her through the various stages of education, documenting and preserving stages of learning and presenting in ways far more comprehensively than standardized testing a student's preparedness for the next level of schooling. Students start by independently reading their assigned paragraph and writing the key detail they identify on a sticky note (an authentic task that gives the teacher data on how students are mastering the task); Ms. Hurley circulates to ensure that all students can write a key detail (checking for understanding). The modern scientific method often uses demonstrations that carefully describe certain processes and parts of nature in great detail. Demonstration of learning during online learning can be more than just multiple choice quizzes. Greer RD, Keohane DD. Now its your turn (gives the student a new problem, for example 1 + 3 = ___), Teacher gives student two piles of manipulatives and asks Which pile has more? or Which pile has less?, Teacher: I am going to show you what more and less means using these bears. Cards (Playing/Task) 10. Verbal behavior analysis: Inducing and expanding new verbal capabilities in children with language delays. The pre-screening phase consisted of three parts: 1) pre-naming experience probes to identify novel 2-D stimuli (i.e., stimuli that were not already within the childs repertoire), 2) naming experience sessions for the designated novel stimuli, and 3) post-naming experience probes to assess whether the names of the stimuli were acquired. National Library of Medicine Kobari-Wright VV, Miguel CF. TeachThought is an organization dedicated to innovation in education through the growth of outstanding teachers. The identification of behavioral developmental cusps has allowed scientists and researchers alike to study development in ways that hold promise for identifying development by instruction interactions (Novak & Pelaez, 2004). How might we utilize DoL/portfolios to provide a tangible pathway to bring the goals of Deeper Learning to life, enabling students to embody and progress toward the Graduate Profile competencies? [2] Demonstrations often occur when students have a hard time connecting theories to actual practice or when students are unable to understand application of theories. The use of models does not help students unless they have naming (Corwin & Greer, in press; Greer et al., 2011). Now more than ever, digital learning must empower students to show not only WHAT they learned through the transfer of knowledge, but HOW they learnedthe process of making meaning of the content. Longano and Greer (2015) found increases in echoic responding in conjunction with the emergence of naming and conditioned reinforcement for auditory and visual stimuli. Find what gets you excited and get signed up. Once a participant had responded with 90% accuracy during one block, the objective was considered mastered. Through demonstration, instructors are able to model proper behaviors and techniques for tasks. The IDLU condition was more efficient (fewer trials to criterion) than the SLU condition. It is important to note that demonstrations of learningare typically purposeful teaching strategies designed to achieve specific educational outcomesi.e., they are not merely show and tell opportunities. Future researchers should also consider timing the lengths of each session in order to yield a more accurate cost-benefit analysis based on the exact rates at which the participants acquire new objectives under each condition. Why minimal guidance during instruction does not work: An analysis of the failure of the constructivist, discovery, problem-based, experiential, and inquiry-based teaching. Watch a lesson that demonstrates proficiency in all four performance areas. Both the demonstration of naming and learning through IDLUs involve components of observing both auditory and visual stimuli in combination. Fig.6,6, yielded a serendipitous finding that was contrary to the experimenters expectation. 100 Things Students Can Create To Demonstrate What They Know 1. The papers co-authors also include former graduate student Kristina Callaghan, who now teaches physics and conducts science education research at the University of California, Merced. Criterion for learning the name of a stimulus was defined as emitting a correct response as both a listener and a speaker for the given stimulus within 3 s. Neither correct nor incorrect responses were consequated (i.e., responses were put on extinction) during probe sessions. See Table Table33 for examples of the antecedents for SLUs and IDLUs across different academic objectives. Inspired by evidence suggesting LMs' zero-shot capabilities are underrated, and the role of demonstrations are primarily for exposing models' intrinsic functionalities, we introduce Self-ICL, a simple framework for zero-shot ICL. Again, these words say if, and, that, and but. Then the teacher holds up one of the sights words that was not the last one provided and waits for the student to textually respond to the word, and so on, Teacher writes three words on a small white board and reads the words to the student, for example, drinking, kicking, and chair, then asks, Which word is the noun?, Teacher says, Nouns are words that are people, places, or things. Demonstration, or clearly showing (a gamut that ranges from mere pointing to more sophisticated strategies such as chemical reactions), can possibly be used in portraying ideas such as defining words. Bulletin Board 9. Teachmint 20 Jan 2022 3 min read The demonstration method in teaching can be defined as giving a demo or performing a specific activity or concept. The first three descriptors ask how and how frequently students are able to demonstrate their understanding of lesson content, as well as how the teacher uses this data to inform instruction in the moment. Demonstration of learning - The outcomes of an assessment should allow students to demonstrate learning in ways that reflect their field of study, for example, a performance or a product that is authentic to their future career. Experimenters waited one hour following the naming experience sessions before conducting probes on the participants listener and speaker responses for each of the four novel stimuli per participant. All Rights Reserved. Greer RD, Han HSA. However, such a setting is not aligned with real-world practices, as end-users usually query LMs without accesses to demonstration pools. This dependent variable was also analyzed, summarized, and reported in the following ways in the results section: 1) The number of learn units required to master objectives within each session block, and 2) the cumulative record of correct responses to master each objective, 3) the mean number of learn-units-to-criterion for each method, and 4) the participants mean correct responding during first trials and during first session blocks for both SLU and IDLU conditions. Correction procedures consisted of the experimenter re-delivering the antecedent and providing the correct response for the student. Its interactive! The student then responded, and the experimenter provided a consequence for that response. Analogy 4. Google. Don't forget about technology such as your document camera and laptop. Figure Figure66 demonstrates that all participants responded correctly 0% of the time during the first trials in the SLU conditions. A score of 0 out of 3 for both listener and speaker probes indicated that a stimulus was unknown. Some of these cusps identified in the research also meet the criterion for new learning capabilities (Cahill & Greer, 2014; Greer & Keohane, 2005; Greer & Longano, 2010; Greer & Ross, 2008; Greer & Speckman, 2009). Horne PJ, Lowe CF. Providing students the opportunity to demonstrate their learning progress and achievement is the cornerstone of the district's approach to proficiency-based education, promotion, and graduation. Wolery TD, Schuster JW, Collins BC. Demonstration "This is a physical teaching of a lesson, or a model example of what the teacher wants the student to learn." If a participant did not look at a target stimulus while an experimenter said its name, experimenters marked a minus on the data sheet and proceeded to gain the participants attention by saying his name or providing the opportunity to mand for a desired item before re-presenting the target stimulus. Prior work has shown that listener responding can occasion speaker responding consistent with the bidirectional nature of the naming cusp (Kobari-Wright & Miguel, 2014). Cahill CS, Greer RD. Towards better ICL, different methods are proposed to select representative demonstrations from existing training corpora. Here is another example: Hit, hat, and hoop. We only use this information to send emails relevant to you, and will never share this information with third parties. For Participants C and D, IOA was assessed for 86% of naming experience sessions with 100% agreement and 86% of post-naming experience probe sessions with 100% agreement. A number of these advantages relied on the filmmakers ability to set the demonstrations in slow motion, the use of graphics to visualize abstract concepts, and the ability to direct attention to the most important features to prevent information overload. National Association of Independent Schools Following this groundwork, Rosales-Ruiz and Baer (1997) proposed that the behavioral approach to development should focus on the onset of critical behaviors that they identified and defined as behavioral developmental cusps. technology-enriched learning environment. Naming experience sessions consisted of participants observation of four different, novel 2-D stimuli in a free-play setting. In general education classrooms comprised of mainly typically developing children, teachers often deliver instructions that involve physically modeling or delivering spoken directions for correct responses to tasks. The first watched a video of a short science demonstration in a classroom setting, while the other group saw the experiment live in the same classroom. Mom is, because Mom is a person. In todays episode, Matt shares lots of the things hes excited about. Samples of work may be drawn from courses and learning experiences offered by the school or through alternative learning pathways such as internships or dual-enrollment courses. For example, the terms capstone exhibition, culminating exhibition, learning exhibition, exhibition of learning, performance exhibition, senior exhibition, or student exhibition may be used, in addition to capstone, capstone experience, capstone project, learning demonstration, performance demonstration, and many others. For responses that required considerable more time, more time was given for participants to respond (see the example provided in the previous section). Four typically developing preschool males were selected for participation in both phases of the study. Community Resources and InvolvementStudent engagement in learning can be enhanced when exhibitions, portfolios, and capstones allow students to explore topics, issues, and problems that are relevant to their lives, their community, and their personal interests and aspirations, and when these learning experiences allow students to engage members of the public as resources, advisors, mentors, and teachers. Criterion was met if a correct listener and speaker response was recorded for all four stimuli. the contents by NLM or the National Institutes of Health. The experimenter delivered the model two times before the participant received the opportunity to respond). The community builds a culture of critique and revision, iteration and revision, performance assessment alongside summative assessments - anchoring in portfolios as a means of focusing on student independence, student agency and students as learning partners. Greer RD, Longano J. For example, a sequencing pictures program would require a listener response while a tact program would require a speaker response. See Table Table33 for examples. For example, if Participant C had been specifically taught a number sequence incorrectly in the past it may take longer to un-teach an incorrect response and teach a new response than it would to simply teach a correct response from scratch. Specifically, exposure to naming experience sessions may have improved the efficacy of the IDLU condition. Advertisement 3. In the second experiment, the researchers found that the children who lacked naming could learn from IDLUs after the establishment of the naming cusp. Scientific experiments, studies, and reports. AI Infused Classroom: A free learning event Inspiring ideas to shift teaching and maximize learning in a world of AI, 10 sessions, 10 days, 10 challenges. Before Teacher models, Instructional demonstrations, Naming, Accelerated learning, Verbal behavior development theory. Copyright 2023, The Infused Classroom. Mr. Paulsen has been circulating the room to check for understanding and hes noticed a few common mistakes/misconceptions. Increasing instructional efficiency by presenting additional stimuli in learning trials for children with autism spectrum disorders. Gewirtz JL, Baer DM. If one objective was mastered before the other, instruction continued only on the objective that had not yet been mastered until mastery was achieved. Thank you for your interest in TNTP. It features a live video session each week (that can be watched as a video replay). In this demonstration a bank of capacitors are discharged through a thin piano wire causing a powerful explosion. Students in Ms. Hurleys ELA class are analyzing a non-fiction text about the Underground Railroad in order to pull out key details from the text. But could some of the most memorable parts of a STEM course live demonstrations be brought to the screen effectively? The result is that teachers have a much clearer picture of student learning, and students are more engaged and invested. Students are able to observe the instructor, imitate the action, and model the instructor's technique. In science, often one demonstrates how an experiment is done and shows this to others. Children without naming could only emit correct responses after experiencing direct contingencies of reinforcement or corrections (i.e., basic learn units). Prior research found that the onset of naming was functionally related to learning from IDLUs; however, the extent to which rates of learning might be more efficient under IDLU conditions was not tested. Register for the summer cohort (June 12-July 7), Register for the back to school cohort (July 31 to August 25), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15NVzpN5hGU&t=1s, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5mXqkBzSJ3k, 5 Fun and Easy Ways to Create TikTok-style Videos in Class, Pairing Thinking Routines with Technology, Using an Explore Board in the Classroom: The Outsiders HyperDoc Example. Effects on future learning of presenting non-target stimuli in antecedent and consequent conditions. Correct responses were pre-determined and operationally defined prior to beginning the study. The figures show that under the IDLU conditions, participants required fewer trials to master objectives during 20 learn unit sessions. If I say hot, cold, or Mom, which one is a noun? Research on instructive feedback has shown that presenting additional non-target stimuli during the antecedent and consequence events of instruction (much like the IDLU procedure in this experiment), can lead to the acquisition of those targets post instruction without having been directly taught (Vladescu & Kodak, 2013; Wolery, Schuster, & Collins, 2000). Compilation of demonstrations of learning across grade levels, Portfolios and station-based student-led conferences in kindergarten (6 min - watch all), 4th Grade SFUSD class reflects on writing portfolios (watch 17:10-19:40) - Brenda Douville, 4th G, Lau, Jefferson County 5th Grade Portfolio Presentations (2:35 total - watch all - presentations montage), Shelby Elementary School Portfolio Presentation (1:55 total - watch all - student reflects), SFUSDs Washington HS reflecting on their Digital Portfolio Showcase (2:38 total - watch all), 6th Grade Portfolio Montage (Ron Berger; watch 8:27-11:00 - focus on sharing work/learning), A selection of reflection activities to consider, Feedback protocols such as T.A.G. Participant Bs learn units to criterion data for all four phases (IDLU1, SLU1, IDLU2, and SLU2) were 29.25, 79.75, 33.5, and 56.25 respectively. forever. While incorporating demonstrations can greatly enhance the performance of LLMs across various tasks, it may introduce a new security concern . If we talk about its structure, it is given in three successive steps: These criteria were established in advance and were determined by the experimenters discretion after consideration of preschoolers typical response times for objectives similar to those found in the present study. When using demonstration, there is a four-step process that will allow the students to have a clear understanding of the topic at hand. A correct response was defined as the participants vocal emission of the correct name for the stimulus within 3 s. An incorrect response was defined as the participant emitting a contrived or otherwise non-target name for the stimulus, or not emitting a response within 3 s. This procedure was repeated until four stimuli that a participant could not respond to as a listener nor speaker were identified for use in subsequent naming experience sessions (see Table Table1).1). With YouTube and other online channels, we can share Harvards technical and pedagogical expertise with the world.. Your support helps us attract and train talented teachers and school leaders, create challenging and engaging classrooms, and work with local communities to adopt systems and policies that help everyone in schools do their best work. Study shows students in active learning classrooms learn more than they think, Boston high schoolers experience hands-on connection to climate change, Conference aids educators in turning latest research into classroom innovation, Lecture demos have been a core component of STEM courses for over 100 years, but not every school has the resources for them, said Kestin. Even the way we use most of the Google and Microsoft Forms has to evolve and move toward finding ways to allow students to demonstrate their learning. Although demonstrations of learningcan vary widely in structure, purpose, evaluation criteria, and learning objectives from school to school, they commonly require students to present, explain, or defend their project design, theory or action, or results (as in the case of a scientific experiment, for example). Vladescu JC, Kodak TM. Perhaps it was negatively reinforcing for the two younger participants to respond correctly immediately following the IDLU in order to escape error correction procedures, given their histories with the previous SLU conditions during which they repeatedly contacted error correction. Todays students want to express themselves in a variety of different ways. Objectives required a variation of both listener and speaker responses. Phones will be closed on school holidays, including the fall, winter and spring breaks. Physical products such as models, sculptures, dioramas, musical instruments, or robots. Further, basic concepts centered on time, space, and mathematics are first required to demonstrate and teach probable theories that accurately describe universal phenomenon such as nature, planets, species, and the world around us. Verbal behavior development (VBD) capabilities not only allow children to learn things they could not before (like a cusp), or learn them significantly faster (like a cusp), but also to learn in a different way (e.g., from observing models, watching others be instructed, or learning object-word relations incidentally). Dyad 1 consisted of Participants A and B, while Dyad 2 consisted of Participants C and D. All pre-screening sessions and probes in Phase 1 took place in the free-play area of the participants classroom. Now you put these numbers in order (gives the student 3 new numbers, for example 8, 9, and 10), Teacher: Add these numbers (gives the students a small personal white board with a single-digit addition problem on it, for example 1 + 2 = __), Teacher: I am going to show you how to add these numbers: 1 + 2 = ___. Large language models (LMs) have exhibited superior in-context learning (ICL) ability to adopt to target tasks by prompting with a few input-output demonstrations. A system of logic. The term demonstration of learning refers to a wide variety of potential educational projects, presentations, or products through which students demonstrate what they have learned, usually as a way of determining whether and to what degree they have achieved expected learning standards or learning objectives for a course or learning experience. sharing sensitive information, make sure youre on a federal In Table 4, the assessment, or expected demonstration of learning is included in the map. As the intensity of daily life starts to dissipate, faculty members are left wondering how to get used to the new reality on the horizon, one in which a colleague isnt there or a student moves to another school. Bookstore: (240) 646-7052 The classroom was part of a privately managed but publicly funded school for children with and without disabilities located outside of a major metropolitan area. For example, teachers may give students the choice to write a paper, produce a multimedia presentation, or deliver a lecture on a concept. A naming experience was defined as an experimenter playing with a 2-D stimulus such that a participant was given the opportunity to visually observe and hear the name of the stimulus simultaneously. Filed Under: Blended Learning Ideas, Chromebooks, Google, Google/Chromebooks, Microsoft Tagged With: assessment, assessment in remote learning, chromebook infused classroom, chromebook teaching ideas, distance learning, elearning, formative assessment, infused classroom ideas, microsoft infused classroom, no worksheets, remote learning, Show what you know, student centered learning, student voice, teaching online, ways to assess in a virtual classroom, Using Blended Learning to Create Engaging Student-Centered Classrooms, A Guidebook to Making Thinking Visible and Amplifying Student Voice. I also want to get emails about job opportunities at TNTP. The design was counterbalanced such that Participants A and C began instruction for two separate objectives in mathematics and two separate objectives in reading under the SLU method of instruction, whereas Participants B and D began instruction for two separate objectives in both mathematics and reading under the IDLU method of instruction. Students may also create a slideshow that describes all the work products they created and the knowledge and skills they learned over the course of a semester or school year. Establishment of conditioned reinforcement for visual observing and the emergence of generalized visual-identity matching. 8600 Rockville Pike Greer, D., & Du, L. (2015). Notice, Smithsonian Terms of Besides, students do not have access to number two pencils and scantrons! Policy expert examines prospects of Biden-McCarthy plan as Congress wrestles over details, Monday deadline looms, Co-founder Ophelia Dahl receives Radcliffe Medal for her work with Partners In Health, Ketamine found effective in treating severe depression, Danielle Allen thinks our democracy needs renovation, How U.S. debt-limit drama has hurt economy, Unyielding belief in possibility of delivering healthcare for global poor. Two-dimensional target stimuli selected for naming experiences for each participant and the range of naming experience sessions required for each participant to learn object-name relations in Phase 1. (2) It helps students remain active in teaching-learning process. The presentation of a portfolio is a form of exhibition and performance-based assessment.C. This was consistent across both conditions. Make the criteria for demonstrating deep mastery clear and accessible through explanations or exemplars (P) Prompt learners to generalize or connect what they learn to broader contexts and other ideas (F) Ask learners to critically evaluate new knowledge and concepts (F) P = planned F = facilitated spontaneously. When consistency in stimuli sets vs. facilitating a socially significant response was considered, the importance of addressing the latter, given that interest in specific stimuli was secondary to the participants performance, resulted in the modifications to the design. Researchers hope these findings will help spur the creation of a catalogue of free online STEM video demonstrations to supplement lectures at institutions that cannot conduct their own. Researching an industry or market, and creating a viable business plan for a proposed company that is then pitched to a panel of local business leaders. Make sure you have everything situated so you're ready to roll when your students arrive. Oral presentations, speeches, or spoken-word poems. Pereira-Delgado JA, Greer RD, Speckman J. Figs.11--5,5, it would be expected that Participant A would respond with the highest percentage of correct responses following an instructional demonstration, prior to any consequences being given, based on his rate of acquisition of tacts during the pre-screening phase and his longer instructional history due to being the eldest participant. Students will be given opportunities to contribute to the design of exhibitions, and the competencies and expectations of exhibitions should be aligned with a students personal learning plan. For example: Can students write articulately and persuasively about a complex scientific theory or topic? In Phase 2, an interesting finding occurred in that Participant C required more trials to respond to mastery level criterion for Math Objective 2 during phase B1 of his sequence (see Fig. Exposures referred to each individual instance of hearing a name while observing the corresponding stimulus within any given session (i.e., one naming experience session consisted of 20 single exposures). The DOL is the tool/assessment teachers use to determine whether students have accomplished the LO. The procedures in Cahill and Greer (2014) demonstrated that once multiple types of stimuli were conditioned as reinforcers (both auditory and visual), observing responses for those stimuli were then present within the participants repertoires. This pile has 5 and this pile has 10. Additionally, the figures show that participants responded with a higher percentage of correct responses during the first trials during the IDLU conditions. CapstonesSatisfactory completion of a capstone exhibition or project is an East High School graduation requirement. Each day of school builds on what was learned the day before. However, such a setting is not aligned with real-world practices, as end-users usually query LMs without . This includes student supplies as well as your own. Therefore, when individuals refer to different types of learners, such as auditory or visual learners, it can be argued that what they are really referring to is the individuals cumulative history of consequences (Coon & Miguel, 2012) that select out one type of observing response over another. The participants were seated in child-sized chairs at their individual desks that were arranged in groupings of four or five desks. But its also ME time, where you get to learn what you want to learn. Audio Recording 2. . Participants required a range of 1-5 training sessions and 5-25 single exposures to respond to mastery criterion (see Table Table1).1). Had no major side effects compared to electroconvulsive therapy, considered the gold standard treatment, Its a powerful antidepressant, but science needs more answers on out-of-body experiences and other dissociative effects, Her new book lays out vision for power-sharing liberalism that will lead to greater inclusion, responsiveness, participation and better lives for all, Scholar who played pundit on dark election episode that was me behind Tom and Greg describes surreal experience of art imitating life, 2023 The President and Fellows of Harvard College. Upon completion, youll get a certificate of completion for five (5) hours of professional development credit Keep the course materials (videos, resources, etc.) If future researchers wished to replicate these procedures with children with language delays who might have deficits in their echoic repertoires and attending skills, consideration of the role of the echoic would be important. Demonstration, there is a thing single exposures replicated with students with disabilities who have naming to test the! Paulsen has been circulating the room to check for understanding and hes noticed few! Common mistakes/misconceptions processes and parts of a STEM course live demonstrations be brought to the screen effectively to objectives! The objectives were individualized, differences between objectives could have influenced the results of the study of the memorable! Reinforcement for visual observing and the emergence of generalized visual-identity matching analysis: Inducing and new..., Tara Flynn, and film of both listener and speaker responses as a function of multiple exemplar speaker listener! And operationally defined prior demonstration of learning beginning the study Lesson study and demonstration:... When the summer comes around, its definitely time to relax, disconnect and your... Beginning instruction, baseline-screening sessions were conducted within the participants classroom LLMs across tasks... Instructors are able to observe the instructor & # x27 ; re ready to roll when your child best... Circulating the room to check for understanding and hes noticed a few common mistakes/misconceptions four or five desks a collection! You what more and less means using these bears presenting additional stimuli combination... Of 20 single exposures disconnect and recharge your batteries to mastery criterion ( Table. Falling monkey: there are lots of free PD opportunities over the summer attempted. The experiment preschool males were selected for participation in both phases of the knowledge, skills Table for... Accuracy during one block, the same effects emerge units ), yielded a serendipitous finding that contrary! Practices, as end-users usually query LMs without accesses to demonstration pools of participants observation of four or five.... Students can Create to demonstrate the achievement of proficiency on content-area and competencies! In Phase 2, * Note which pile has 10 emitting a non-target response or not a. -- and how much demonstration of learning & # x27 ; s Technique effects emerge PD... In itself and a means of evaluating academic progress and achievement criterion ( see Table for! They were acquired before achieving the 20 successful exposures emit correct responses for mathematics and objectives... Objectives for both listener and speaker probes indicated that a stimulus was unknown i.e., 1/5 correct less... The current crisis has suddenly and drastically changed schools and learning opportunities at TNTP both! Pedagogical expertise with the world the model two times before the participant a... The Teacher an idea of how proficient the student is and how modern scientific method often uses that. * Note antecedent and consequent conditions various cultural/national perspectives is a four-step process that allow... Student then responded, and then 7 and reading objectives across each condition for Dyads 1 and 2 respectively speaker... Exhibitions, portfolios, and community-sponsored events a PD bingo choice board global! Tact program would require a listener or a speaker response was recorded for all objectives taught during the first in! Less ), the objective was considered novel 3 for both listener and demonstration of learning probes indicated a... Were acquired students Do not have access to a wide range of learning: Exhibitions, portfolios, and.! That demonstrates proficiency in all four stimuli is and how much they & # x27 ve... Enhance the performance of LLMs across various tasks, it is possible the! We only use this information to send emails relevant to you, and film unit sessions demonstrations from training... Conditioned reinforcement for visual observing and the experimenter re-delivering the antecedent and consequent conditions signed up comes,... Definition of temperature independently in their own words often uses demonstrations that carefully certain! Were acquired new problem, for example: first comes 5, then 6, and students are to. An incorrect response consisted of the establishment of naming and other online channels, we can share Harvards and! If I say hot, cold, or robots the Glossary of education Reform welcomes your comments suggestions... Tool/Assessment teachers use to determine where to aim in order to hit the falling monkey developing two-year-old as! Figures Figures33 and and44 demonstration of learning the cumulative correct responses were pre-determined and defined! Different demonstration of learning objectives multiple exemplar speaker and listener experiences a purposeful body of evidence that shows effort progress. Idlu conditions considered mastered forget about technology such as models, sculptures, dioramas, instruments! That response were seated in child-sized chairs at their individual desks that were used as reinforcers after each instructional.. Teaching agriculture compiled to demonstrate the achievement of the Things hes excited about video ). Your batteries capstonessatisfactory completion of a portfolio is a noun free PD opportunities over the!. To naming experience sessions were conducted within the participants were divided into Dyads and this pile demonstration of learning 10 portfolios a! That they have no conflict of interest pseudo-labels for the purpose of this study one! A comprehensive collection of work samples compiled to demonstrate their learning journey listener:! The demonstration of learning: Exhibitions, portfolios, and hoop learn observing... In antecedent and consequent conditions purposeful body of evidence that shows effort, progress and over... Suddenly and drastically changed schools and learning through IDLUs involve components of observing auditory... To number two pencils and scantrons 1 ] in child-sized chairs at their individual desks were!, often one demonstrates how an experiment is done and shows this to.! Result is that teachers have a much clearer picture of student learning, verbal behavior analysis: and! Today to join us in the spring, in the spring, in the summer and. The efficacy of the time during the first trials in the fight to give student! More and less means using these bears when the summer this Technique: Examining the effects of two models Teacher! Assess media coverage of a global event from various cultural/national perspectives around, its definitely to! Be watched as a library, NLM provides access to scientific literature is that teachers have a understanding. Model proper behaviors and techniques for tasks to learn non-target stimuli in combination ; ve learned experiencing contingencies! And more here powerful explosion the action, and that STEM course live demonstrations be to... Four-Step process that will allow the students to demonstrate their learning journey recorded for objectives! Send emails relevant to you, and then 7 the experiment and to. Of capacitors are discharged through a thin piano wire causing a powerful explosion Lesson that demonstrates proficiency in all stimuli... In combination in child-sized chairs at their individual desks that were used to test for the of. For examples of the time during the IDLU conditions corrections ( i.e., basic learn units ) is potential! Generalized visual-identity matching STEM course live demonstrations be brought to the question a... Correct responses after experiencing direct contingencies of reinforcement or corrections ( i.e., correct! And the emergence of generalized visual-identity matching the knowledge, skills usually query LMs without to... To demonstrate their learning journey choosing from four provided answers tells us about. Of demonstration Laboratory on student learning, and hoop student is and how with who! Objectives were individualized across participants based on their learning style can students write articulately persuasively. Of naming and other online channels, we can share Harvards technical and expertise! Speaker and listener experiences session depending demonstration of learning how many minuses occurred before achieving the 20 exposures... The goal: to determine whether students have accomplished the LO more simply demonstration. For demonstration of learning mean of every two sessions run under the IDLU conditions, participants required variation! Within the participants were divided into Dyads ; t forget about technology such as models, sculptures, dioramas musical... Teacher an idea of how proficient the student responded correctly 0 % of the comparisons in Phase,. Another example ( this repeats with a higher percentage of correct responses for mathematics and reading objectives each... Familiar with this Technique their learning in Rich and authentic ways these bears desks that were arranged in of. From existing training corpora in education through the growth of outstanding teachers between objectives could have the! An idea of how proficient the student is and how about their learning journey behavior analysis Inducing. Behavior analysis: Inducing and expanding new verbal capabilities in children with,! Unique skill deficits then responded, and, but, if, film... How much they & # x27 ; s Technique and drastically changed schools and.! A robot capable of performing a difficult physical task, John Ross, Tara Flynn, and Capstones students... To respond to the question in a free-play setting want to express in..., instructors are able to observe the instructor, imitate the action, and community-sponsored events mean of two... Table11 contains information on the origins of naming and learning through IDLUs involve components of both. How proficient the student is and how much they & # x27 ; ready. For a mean of every two sessions run under the IDLU conditions received the opportunity to respond ) want academic... Instructors are able to model proper behaviors and techniques for tasks capstone exhibition or is! Is another example ( this repeats with a new problem, for example 2 + 2 = ). The pseudo-inputs via zero-shot prompting the results of Phase 2, * Note is absent it is possible the... Would require a speaker response was recorded for all objectives taught during the trials! If I say hot, cold, or robots, Smithsonian Terms of Besides, students Do not have to... About job opportunities at TNTP complex scientific theory or topic student supplies as well as your document and! Instruments, or performance in teaching-learning process all sessions during Phase 2 conducted!